Welcome to The New Everything Croton, a collection of all things Croton -- our history, our homes, our issues, our businesses, our schools, our houses of worship -- in short, EVERYTHING CROTON.
Although most Croton ghost stories date to the 18th and 19th centuries, the tales about the ghost haunting the Harmon Playhouse—said to be Clifford Harmon himself—appear to date to the 1940s. Now a private home on Truesdale Drive, adjacent to the home that was the Nikko Inn, the Playhouse hosted theatrical productions from roughly 1908 into the 1930s until it was purchased by Dr. Samuel Kahn, a controversial psychiatrist and psychoanalyst who had studied with Freud.
While living in the house the Kahns became interested in psychics and invited one to visit. Accompanying her was Hans Holzer, an Austrian-American author and parapsychologist. He wrote more than 120 books on supernatural and occult subjects as well as several plays, musicals, films, and documentaries, and he hosted a television show, Ghost Hunter.
After the psychic demonstrated her abilities to the Kahns and a group of their friends and neighbors, Holzer spoke to Mrs. Kahn who said, “You know, I think we’ve got a ghost.”
“He’s a whistling ghost,” she confided, “always whistling the same song . . . a happy tune. I guess he must be a happy ghost!” Mrs. Kahn explained that although her husband had never heard the whistling, he heard strange raps in their bedroom, late at night. The previous winter they both heard loud knocking on their front door, but when they opened it there was no one there.
As Holzer questioned the Kahns about the history of the house and their experiences he became convinced that the ghost was Clifford Harmon himself, who the Kahns said—incorrectly—had been murdered by the Nazis during World War II.
A medium was later brought in to communicate with Harmon and other spirits in the house. Holzer pieced together their stories of a lost love between Harmon and a woman and jealous man who would knock on the front door.
In 1975 the house was purchased by Mike and Lucy Martineau. Mike was a talent agent, who represented groups like the Commodores and Average White Band, and Lucy was a model.
They had heard the ghost stories before they bought the house, but thought the whole thing was very funny . . . until strange things started to happen.
They’d come home and find all the lights in Mike’s photographic studio on; mirrors smashed into powdered glass or simply removed from the walls and placed on the floor; doors with triple latches unlocked, and other unexplainable occurrences. Several friends from England and Europe had stayed in the house one night and vowed never to stay again.
Lucy Martineau managed to track down Hans Holzer. “Holzer wore a smoking jacket,” she told the Ossining Citizen-Register in 1977, “and had an accent like Bela Lugosi.”
He agreed to hold another seance, with a medium from New Jersey, who communicated with two more ghosts. One was a woman who was waiting for her dead husband and son to come home. The other was a man named Ralph, who had been cheated in a business deal, killed one of his partners, and was hiding out from the police. Holzer convinced both ghosts to leave and the Martineaus recalled that when the ghosts left, the temperature in the room dropped by about 20 degrees.
The strange occurrences didn’t stop after the seance, but Lucy and Mike reported that they were no longer frightened their ghostly housemates.
This was originally published in the Fall 2021 issue of our quarterly newsletter, The Croton Historian. You can subscribe for $10 a year.
Please make your check payable to Croton Historical Society and mail it to:
Croton Historical Society
1 Van Wyck Street
Croton-on-Hudson, NY 10520